The Dollar Sale is on now!

The Dollar Sale at Premier: Double Up for a Buck on over 100 select wines!

The Dollar Sale is on now at Premier! For a limited time and on select wines, when you buy one bottle at regular price, get a second identical bottle for just ONE DOLLAR! DOUBLE UP FOR A BUCK!

Finger Lakes Wines

Finger Lakes Wines

Shop for Wines from NY's Finger Lakes

The bulk of Finger Lake wines come from Keuka, Cayuga and Seneca Lake wineries, with a small percentage from Canadaigua and other minor lakes.

The cool climate is most often compared to that of Germany, and the major European grapes of the area are the classic Eastern European varieties of Riesling, Gewurztraminer, Lemberger, Cabernet Franc and Pinot Noir.

Dr. Konstantin Frank and Hermann J. Wiemer are the prominent wineries for those classic wines. In addition, indigenous grapes like Niagara and Concord, and French-American hybrids are planted because of their heartiness towards the harsh winters, and produce fruit-forward, light- to medium-bodied reds, whites and roses to suit a variety of palates.

View as Grid List

Items 1-15 of 348

Set Ascending Direction
per page
Shop By
Shopping Options
Wine Type
  1. Table Wine 317items
  2. Sparkling Wine 8items
  3. Fortified Wine 2items
  4. Fruit & Flavored Wines 7items
  5. Dessert Wine 3items
  6. none 7items
Package Size
  1. 750 ml. 299items
  2. 1.5 L. 35items
  3. 3.0 L. 4items
  4. 375 ml. 9items
  5. 500 ml. 1item
Vintage
  1. 2014 1item
  2. 2015 2items
  3. 2017 8items
  4. 2018 17items
  5. 2019 37items
  6. 2020 76items
  7. 2001 1item
  8. 2003 1item
  9. 2013 1item
  10. 2021 89items
  11. NV 115items
  1. Great Buffalo Premier Red

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#16453

    Premier SelectPremier Select wines are handpicked by our staff from amongst thousands of wines for their exceptional quality. They're made by a top producer and comparable to wines at twice the cost.
    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Either the bottle is too large for our packaging (i.e. we cannot ship anything larger than 750 ml), the dimensions/shape of the bottle doesn't fit within our packaging for safe shipment, or this is a widely-distributed wine (e.g. Barefoot, Yellow Tail, etc) which we only sell at our physical store or for in-store pickup.

    Compare at $9.99 $7.99

    You save: $2.00 (20%)

  2. Great Buffalo Premier White

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#16454

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Either the bottle is too large for our packaging (i.e. we cannot ship anything larger than 750 ml), the dimensions/shape of the bottle doesn't fit within our packaging for safe shipment, or this is a widely-distributed wine (e.g. Barefoot, Yellow Tail, etc) which we only sell at our physical store or for in-store pickup.

    Compare at $9.99 $7.99

    You save: $2.00 (20%)

  3. $16.99

    Only $15.29 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  4. Dr. Konstantin Frank Dry Riesling

    2021 / 750 ml. | Item#77978

    JS9191 pts. - JamesSuckling.com - Tuesday, August 9, 2022
    A lot of floral delicacy and lemon and lime zest, but also some good white-peach fruit behind those high notes. Good depth on the mid-palate for the challenging vintage, with some wet-stone character at the long, crisp finish. Made from fruit grown on Kueka Lake and Seneca Lake. Drink or hold. Screw cap.
    RP8989 pts. - Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate - 12th May 2022
    The 2021 Dry Riesling comes in with eight grams per liter of residual sugar, 7.9 of total acidity and 12% alcohol. I haven’t been liking a lot of what I’m seeing from this vintage (to be sure, there haven’t been a lot of examples yet), but this seems awfully nice. Fresh, balanced and lively, this adds a juicy, tense finish, and the fruit occasionally asserts itself. It’s elegant in the mid-palate, dancing across the tongue. I’ll be interested to see if this can hold form or improve in a couple of years, but right now it is a fine choice at a nice price point. Of course, it is a serious Dry Riesling. If you like them sweeter or fruitier, this is not for you. (Mark Squires)
    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Riesling | All Grapes: Riesling

    Compare at $17.99 $15.99

    You save: $2.00 (11%)

  5. Compare at $17.99 $15.99

    You save: $2.00 (11%)

  6. $15.99

    Only $14.39 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  7. $16.99

    Only $15.29 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  8. $11.99

    Only $10.79 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  9. $11.99

    Only $10.79 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  10. $26.99

    Only $24.29 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  11. $12.99

    Only $11.69 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  12. $31.99

    Only $28.79 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  13. Compare at $12.99 $9.99

    You save: $3.00 (23%)

  14. Wagner Riesling Select

    2020 / 750 ml. | Item#72096

    RP9090 pts. - Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate - 12th May 2022
    The 2020 Riesling Select comes in with 33 grams of residual sugar, 7.5 of total acidity and 12.5% alcohol. This is the “select” because the fruit is sourced from the winery’s Heritage block. The winery says it’s “the first Riesling vineyard planted by founder Bill Wagner in 1977. These 45-year-old wines continue to produce compelling fruit.” Indeed. There are lots of bargains in the Finger Lakes, a region that often overachieves, but this is a consistent value. The sugar is up first, circling around the edges and making this quite delicious, but this is not a wine ruled by the sugar, as high as that number is. In fact, the acidity balances it perfectly, making this suitable for use even as a table wine. It’s fresh and persistent with a beautiful finish. The fruit shows its clean purity all the while. It’s another impressive overachiever from this winery. (Mark Squires)
    SP8888 pts. - Wine Spectator - Dec 15, 2021
    Very direct, with yellow apple, fennel and white peach flavors racing through, Backed by an off-dry edge that gives the finish a flattering feel while maintaining freshness. Drink now through 2022. 915 cases made. (James Molesworth)
    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Riesling | All Grapes: Riesling

    Limited Inventory

    5 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $14.99

    Only $13.49 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

  15. $19.99

    Only $17.99 each when you buy a solid or mixed case

per page