Member store of the Premier Group member store

Member of the Premier Group

Shop online and get FREE curbside pickup, with the same great prices as in store!

Toggle Nav

Premier Wine & Spirits
3900 Maple Road, Amherst, NY 14226
Call Us: 716-873-6688

  • Sign In
  • Create an Account
My Cart
Menu
Account

FREE curbside pickup on any order!

Curbside and In-Store Pickup Orders

Get FREE curbside pickup on any order! Orders are typically taking 1-2 business hours to complete at this time. Please wait for an email confirming that your order is ready before coming to the store.

FREE Shipping to New York State on orders over $150!

Special Offer: Get FREE Shipping within New York State on orders over $150!

Now you can get FREE ground shipping to destinations within New York state on orders over $150! There's no coupon code necessary! This applies to 750ml bottles of wine only.

Narrow Your Search
Shopping Options
Wine - Color
Red 6 items
White 2 items
Less
Price
-
Primary Grape
  1. Chardonnay 1item
  2. Aglianico 1item
  3. Pecorino 1item
  4. Sangiovese 5items
Less
Region
  1. Tuscany 5items
  2. Abruzzo 1item
  3. Basilicata 1item
  4. Sicily 1item
Less
Rating Source
  1. Wine Spectator 2items
  2. Robert Parker 4items
  3. Vinous 2items
Less
Rating
Awards and Accolades
  1. Premier Select 1item
Less
Spec. Designation
  1. Organic 2items
Less
Vintage
  1. 2015 1item
  2. 2016 2items
  3. 2017 1item
  4. 2019 2items
  5. 2020 1item
  6. 2011 1item
Less
Compare Products
  1. Remove This Item
Compare
Clear All
You have no items to compare.
My Wish List
Last Added Items
  1. Add to Cart
    Remove This Item
Go to Wish List
You have no items in your wish list.

Top-Rated Italian Wines

Top-Rated Italian Wines | WineDeals.com

Take a journey through the Italian countryside with these top-rated Italian wines. Wine critics loved them, and you will, too!

View as Grid List

8 Items

Set Ascending Direction
per page
Narrow Your Search
Shopping Options
Vintage
  1. 2015 1item
  2. 2016 2items
  3. 2017 1item
  4. 2019 2items
  5. 2020 1item
  6. 2011 1item
Less
  1. Colle Bereto Chianti Classico
    Colle Bereto Chianti Classico

    2017 / 750 ml. | Item#94038

    SP9494 pts. - Wine Spectator - Oct 15, 2020
    Aromas of blood, iron and raw beef lead off, followed by flavors of cherry, plum and leather. Rich and harmonious, with a dense underlying structure and terrific length. Approachable now, but this should evolve well over the next few decades. Drink now through 2040. 3,500 cases made, 2,800 cases imported.     JS9191 pts. - JamesSuckling.com - Thursday, November 7, 2019
    Lots of dried peppers here, as well as earth, dried plums and spices. Firm and tangy on the medium-bodied palate, but quite succulent on the finish. Lemon-zest aftertaste. Drink now.
    Premier SelectPremier Select wines are handpicked by our staff from amongst thousands of wines for their exceptional quality. They're made by a top producer and comparable to wines at twice the cost.
    Product Location

    Italy | Tuscany | Chianti Classico

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Sangiovese | All Grapes: 97% Sangiovese

    Compare at $29.99 $19.99

    You save: $10.00 (33%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  2. Basilisco
    Basilisco

    Aglianico del Vulture
    2011 / 750 ml. | Item#92649

    RP9393 pts. - Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate - 29th Apr 2015
    The 2011 Aglianico del Vulture Basilisco is from the hottest vintage among the three wines (2009, 2010 and 2011) I tasted in this mini-vertical. In many ways, this is the most immediate and successful of the three wines thanks to the fact that the ripe fruit adds softness and fleshiness to counter the natural astringency of the Aglianico grape. Generous spice, tobacco and blackberry fruit are woven together with a thick and penetrating texture. Sweet tobacco appears on the close and signals that this wine is only at the beginning of a long evolution.     JS9090 pts. - JamesSuckling.com - Monday, October 22, 2018
    This red shows aromas of tar, dark berries and wet earth that follow through to a full body, juicy and ripe fruit and a firm tannin structure. Pretty wine that needs drinking now.
    Product Location

    Italy | Basilicata | Aglianico del Vulture

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Aglianico | All Grapes: 100% Aglianico del Vulture

    Compare at $29.99 $19.99

    You save: $10.00 (33%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  3. Planeta Chardonnay
    Planeta Chardonnay

    2019 / 750 ml. | Item#95361

    VN9090 pts. - Vinous - Jun 2021
    The sweetly scented 2019 Chardonnay opens up with an alluring bouquet of dusty yellow florals, dried apricot, sage and hints of almond. It boasts oily, glycerol-like textures, lifted by stimulating acids, citrus-tinged orchard fruits and minerals. This is rich and savory with power in reserve, tapering off a bit tropical yet in perfect balance. A salty flourish keeps you coming back to the glass for more.
    Product Location

    Italy | Sicily | Menfi

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Chardonnay | All Grapes: 100% Chardonnay

    Limited Inventory

    4 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    Compare at $44.99 $35.99

    You save: $9.00 (20%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  4. Torre Raone Raone Pecorino
    Torre Raone Raone Pecorino

    2020 / 750 ml. | Item#95143

    VN9090 pts. - Vinous - Apr 2021
    The 2020 Pecorino Raone is very pretty yet understated with a display of honeysuckle, peach and wet stone. Its silky textures are quickly contrasted by a mix of salty minerals and savory spice. Hints of sour melon and green apple resonate beneath an air of tropical florals, as the 2020 tapers off youthfully poised. I recommend giving this another year to flesh out a bit.
    Product Location

    Italy | Abruzzo | Colline Pescaresi

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Pecorino | All Grapes: Pecorino

    DESIGNATIONS

    Organic

    Organic: Made with organic grapes

    Compare at $17.99 $12.99

    You save: $5.00 (28%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  5. Volpaia Chianti Classico
    Volpaia Chianti Classico

    2019 / 750 ml. | Item#84140

    SP9090 pts. - Wine Spectator - Oct 31, 2021
    Juicy cherry, strawberry and currant fruit abounds, along with a savory side sporting thyme, juniper and earth notes. It finishes with dusty tannins. Drink now through 2025. 14,000 cases made, 10,000 cases imported.     WE9090 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 5/1/2022
    A blend of 90% Sangiovese and 10% Merlot, this polished red has aromas of woodland berries and spice with hints of eucalyptus. Made with organically grown grapes, it’s smooth and tangy, offering sour cherry, cranberry and star anise alongside taut, lithe tannins. Drink through 2024.
    Product Location

    Italy | Tuscany | Chianti Classico

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Sangiovese | All Grapes: Sangiovese

    DESIGNATIONS

    Organic

    Organic: Made with organic grapes

    Compare at $24.99 $19.99

    You save: $5.00 (20%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  6. Renieri Brunello di Montalcino
    Renieri Brunello di Montalcino

    2016 / 750 ml. | Item#95038

    JS9696 pts. - JamesSuckling.com - Wednesday, November 11, 2020
    This is a very tight, refined Brunello that shows so much beautiful fruit and polish with dark-berry, cedar, walnut and cherry character. It’s full-bodied with layers of fine tannins and a fresh, pretty finish. Needs much more time to open. Try after 2024.     RP9494 pts. - Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate - 30th Nov 2020
    The Renieri 2016 Brunello di Montalcino is a plush, fruit-forward and accessible wine that captures the purity and elegance of the vintage. The best take-away, however, is the fresh, ready and bright state of this wine that makes it almost ready to enjoy straight out of the gate. This Brunello from a nine-hectare plot with limestone clay soils offers bold cherry and blackberry with delicate spice, smoke and blue flower. The wine is marked by balanced acidity, and there is some tannic tightness that should further relax by the time this wine hits the market at the start of 2021. This is a go-to bottle (in a 50,000 bottle release) if you want a first and memorable taste of the classic 2016 vintage.     SP9393 pts. - Wine Spectator - Jun 30, 2021
    A dense, solid style, this red displays cherry, plum, iron, wild herb and scrub aromas and flavors. Concentrated and compact, needs time to unfurl all its nuances and equilibrium. Best from 2024 through 2042. 4,000 cases made, 1,200 cases imported.     WE9393 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 5/1/2021
    Floral aromas of violet and rose mingle with new leather and menthol on this fragrant red. Racy and linear, the palate features dried cherry, licorice and blood orange set against firm, fine-grained tannins. Drink 2024–2031.     VN9090 pts. - Vinous - Nov 2020
    The 2016 Brunello di Montalcino is a sweetly spiced and fruit-forward expression of the vintage, yet it manages to color within the lines of refinement. Mulled apples and strawberries with a balsamic tinge give way to mentholated herbal tones. It’s soft with a wonderful mix of inner sweetness, pure red berry fruits and minerals, yet it lacks momentum toward the close. Rounded tannins linger along with hints of plum, tobacco and dark inner florals. With the exception of a lull on the mid-palate, the 2016 Renieri is really quite pleasurable, yet it’s better to enjoy this sooner rather than later.
    Product Location

    Italy | Tuscany | Brunello di Montalcino

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Sangiovese | All Grapes: Sangiovese

    Compare at $89.99 $71.99

    You save: $18.00 (20%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  7. Il Poggione Brunello di Montalcino
    Il Poggione Brunello di Montalcino

    2016 / 750 ml. | Item#94504

    VN9797 pts. - Vinous - Nov 2020
    I’m not sure how Il Poggione manages to remain one of the largest producers of Brunello, maintaining such a high level of quality and turning out some of the best wines of the vintage year after year - but they do. The 2016 Brunello di Montalcino is yet another stunning example. Depths of mineral-encased black cherries, sage, allspice, licorice, tobacco and crushed violets lift up from the glass. It’s seamlessly silky, even as the palate is peppered with tart red and black berries, nervous acids and savory exotic spices. This shows the density and weight of the vintage in a youthfully monolithic stance, yet with all the necessary components to maintain perfect balance. The 2016 Il Poggione seems to fold in upon itself through the finish, which is dark, mysterious and structured, with only hints of black tea and licorice to tempt the imagination. It’s a classic in the making.     RP9595 pts. - Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate - 30th Nov 2020
    The Il Poggione 2016 Brunello di Montalcino opens to a medium dark appearance with pretty Sangiovese shine and a little ruby sparkle. This vintage shows a slightly untamed or wild side with a dense and heavier fruit profile. The focus here is on blackberry, dried cherry, tobacco and even a touch of smoky tobacco or horse saddle. The wine shows the firm grip and tannic backbone that is a common trait in this vintage, especially with the vineyards on this southern, sunlit side of the appellation. I also get a considerable flash of acidity on the close, almost too much, that certainly needs a few more years to soften. You really need to wait with this one. Production is an ample 200,000 bottles.     JS9494 pts. - JamesSuckling.com - Wednesday, November 11, 2020
    A red with blackberry, cherry, some walnut and chocolate, as well as mahogany. Tea, too. It’s full-bodied and firm-tannined with beautiful length and depth. Linear and very fine. Drink after 2024.
    Product Location

    Italy | Tuscany | Brunello di Montalcino

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Sangiovese | All Grapes: Sangiovese

    Compare at $99.99 $74.99

    You save: $25.00 (25%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  8. Podere Poggio Scalette Il Carbonaione
    Podere Poggio Scalette Il Carbonaione

    2015 / 750 ml. | Item#88773

    JS9999 pts. - JamesSuckling.com - Saturday, November 3, 2018
    A really exotic nose with so much dried herb character, ranging from thyme and sage to Thai basil. Then there’s more familiar and equally appealing dark blackcurrants, crushed stones and lavender. Full body with very refined tannins that both coat and caress the palate. A long, chewy finish. Drink in 2022.     RP9292 pts. - Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate - 31st Oct 2018
    The 2015 Il Carbonaione presents a thick and darkly saturated side of Sangiovese. This expression opens to a dark garnet color with ripe aromas of black cherry, prune and blackberry. This edition delivers extra thickness and richness, yet that mid-weight approach is never compromised. This wine should spread out and gain in volume as it evolves in the bottle. Some 26,000 bottles were made (whereas only 2,000 bottles of the 2015 Capogatto were produced).     SP9090 pts. - Wine Spectator - Jul 31, 2018
    This is lush, featuring a light touch of oak spice shading black cherry, blackberry and plum flavors. Firm yet well-integrated, with a lingering, fresh finish. Sangiovese. Drink now through 2022. 2,200 cases made.
    Product Location

    Italy | Tuscany | Alta Valle della Greve

    Wine Grapes

    Primary Grape: Sangiovese | All Grapes: Sangiovese

    Compare at $79.99 $59.99

    You save: $20.00 (25%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
per page